Is earned wage access the kinder, gentler face of payday lending?

Photo Credit: Freepik

In principle, there should be absolutely nothing wrong with requesting an “advance” on your weekly or bi-weekly paycheck. When the electrician comes to my house and completes his task, I don’t say “I’ll send you a check in two weeks.” Labor is performed and payment is due on completion. There is no reason (other than convenience) that it should not be that way in general. We should all receive our day’s salary at the end of the workday. Waiting for payday is a zero interest rate loan to your employer. An advance is really not an advance at all.

Just like payday lenders, earned wage access (whereby an employer or a 3rd party fintech makes a portion of wages due available to the payee before the scheduled payday) responds to a real need. Sometimes a bill comes due, or a need arises before the paycheck arrives. It is the classic accounting mismatch between the availability of assets and the timing of liabilities. Many of us respond to this mismatch by using a credit card. But if your credit is poor and that is not an available option, then getting part of your paycheck early can fill the gap quite nicely. And if you can do so at little or no additional cost, why not?

Just like in business, the need to access emergency cash funding is usually a sign of weakness not strength. An advance early in the month to meet an immediate shortfall means a lower paycheck mid-month when all of the normal expenses will still be due. Will the discounted mid-month check be enough? Often not, starting the cycle that we see in payday lending when debts spiral as they are continuously rolled over.

Earned wage access addresses a symptom effectively, without in any way treating the disease.

We are back at the need for emergency savings. Those employers that are experimenting with earned wage access would serve their workers better by supporting interventions that support workers’ ability to create cash cushions. “Sidecar” savings accounts that automate payroll deductions to a liquid savings account, boosted by an employer match, are a far more effective response to the problem supposedly “addressed” by earned wage access schemes.

I do not think that earned wage access is wrong per se; particularly when offered by an employer, it has less potential for the kind of abuse that we see in payday lending. It is a sometimes useful convenience. But it is nothing more than that, and certainly not the panacea to the financial stresses experienced by low and middle wage workers that it is often portrayed to be.




Accredited Financial Counselor®. Exploring the intersection of public policy and financial wellness.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

32 Legitimate Ways to Make Money at Home

Rich dad poor dad.

I believe that his stock will double within 2 years. Here

Slangin’ Tech Support, Bowling Games, Hebrew Lessons and Parental Money: How I Paid $54K in…

We’re Upgrading For Good

Honeygain: Earn money doing nothing, just using internet.

In television history, what does it mean to jump the shark”?”

What you need to know about auto trading bots

Auto trading bots

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Lisa Whitley

Lisa Whitley

Accredited Financial Counselor®. Exploring the intersection of public policy and financial wellness.

More from Medium

Katastrophy Wife’s Amusia Turns 20

Out With the New, in With the Used: Monthly Book Sale Supports Local Libraries

Welcome Babe Basic Equipment for a Child-friendly Home

Welcome babe Basic Equipment for a Child-friendly Home

Unify Dream Machine Pro gets loud after SSD installation